Listing Tools

New Castle mixed use property with water views and in town location! Five units incl. the Islander Cafe, which will continue to stay on to serve breakfast, lunches, coffee and more in the 15 seat restaurant w/add'l outdoor seating for 4, plus 4 deeded parking spaces out front. The Cafe was completely rehabbed down to the studs in 2021-22. All new appliances, flooring, seating, counters, walk in freezer in store room, spacious bath and office, as well as all new cooktops, gas range, ice maker, prep sinks, fridge and wash areas. Breakfast sandwiches and crullers to die for will lure you in and lots more for lunch too! The res. units consist of two-2 bdrms, One-1 bdrm, & 1 studio. The common rear yard is partially fenced in for privacy, grilling, sunning, gardening. Some have waterviews of the Piscataqua River to watch the boat traffic from your deck or window! Hdwd floors & arched doorways are wonderful characteristics of this 1890 building. The orig.lot was owned by the town and used as the minister's "Parsonage Garden", then built into apts. plus Prohaska's Grocery Store with Jennie Britton's ice cream & candy shop, then to the final hands of Henry Greenberg's apartments & store to almost the same usage today! Newer oil heating syst., new roof, updated elect., fire alarm syst, laundry on site. Centered in the quaint village of New Castle, jaunt down the street to the beach, dog park, & lighthouses. nearby Wentworth Golf Course, Wentworth Hotel/Spa & Marina. Low NC taxes.

More Info

Tax Information

  • Tax Year2022


  • Year Built1890
  • Building ConstructionWood Frame
  • StyleApartment Building
  • Units5
  • Unit 1 Bath1
  • Unit 1 Floor Location1
  • Unit 1 Total Rooms2
  • Unit 2 Bath1
  • Unit 2 Bedrooms1
  • Unit 2 Floor Location1
  • Unit 2 Styleground level Rt
  • Unit 2 Total Rooms3
  • Unit 3 Bath1
  • Unit 3 Bedrooms1
  • Unit 3 Floor Location2 rear
  • Unit 3 StyleStudio-WV
  • Unit 3 Total Rooms2
  • Unit 4 Bath1
  • Unit 4 Floor Location2
  • Unit 4 Style2nd FL-WV
  • Unit 4 Total Rooms5
  • Unit 5 Baths1
  • Unit 5 Bedrooms2
  • # of 1 Bedrooms1
  • # of 2 Bedrooms2
  • Bathroom3
  • Total Baths3
  • Basement
    • Bulkhead
    • Dirt Floor
    • Full
    • Partial
    • Stairs - Exterior
    • Unfinished
  • FoundationBlock, Brick, Stone

Basic Information

  • StatusActive With Contract
  • List Price$1,795,000
  • Date Price Change10/13/2023
  • MLS Number4968332
  • MLS StatusActive Under Contract


  • Acreage0.08
  • Parking Spaces
  • Lot DescriptionLevel, Water View
  • Lot55
  • Square Feet3,971
  • APX Fin AG Sqft3,971
  • Road Frontage40
  • RoadsPublic
  • AreaHistoric District, In Town, Near Country Club, Near Golf Course, Village


  • Exterior AmenitiesBalcony, Deck, Fence - Partial, Garden Space, Shed
  • PricePerSqFt452.03

Water Body

  • Water Body TypeRiver
  • Water Body NamePiscataqua River
  • Water ViewYes


  • Taxes$5,677
  • Seasonal Y/NNo
  • TrashCurbside
  • Foot Print Dim36 x 33 + 22 x 16
  • Date Listed09/01/2023
  • Unit 1 Deposit$500
  • Unit 2 Rent Amount$870
  • Unit 3 Rent Amount$950
  • Unit 4 Rent amount$1,800
  • View Count9


  • TownNew Castle
  • StateNH
  • Zip03854
  • CountyRockingham
  • ZoningMU
  • Elementary SchoolMaude H. Trefethen School
  • Junior HighRye Junior High School
  • High SchoolPortsmouth High School
  • Flood Zone Y/NYes


  • FloorsCarpet, Hardwood, Vinyl


  • ExteriorClapboard
  • RoofShingle
  • Exterior ColorBlue


  • Heat FuelOil
  • Heat SystemBaseboard, Hot Water, Multi Zone
  • WaterPublic Water - On-Site
  • Water HeaterSeparate
  • Electric200 Amp, Circuit Breaker(s), Generator Ready
  • SewerPublic Sewer On-Site
  • UtilitiesCable - Available, Internet - Cable, Telephone Available

Map Location

Driving Directions

Broker Reciprocity 

Copyright 2023 PrimeMLS, Inc. All rights reserved. This information is deemed reliable, but not guaranteed. The data relating to real estate displayed on this display comes in part from the IDX Program of PrimeMLS. The information being provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated December 4, 2023 6:23 PM EST


Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:

Do not fill in this field:


Do not fill in this field: